Picture this scenario.
A woman who realizes she has had too much to drink finds a friend to drive her home. She hands him the keys to her car, and they head home, just like all those public service announcements recommend.
But there’s a problem. The car gets pulled over by a police officer who finds the driver doesn’t have a valid license.
Faced with a car driven by an unlicensed driver, the officer wants to know who owns the car. The woman tells the officer the car is hers, but she admits she’s too drunk to drive.
She isn’t belligerent. She’s simply drunk.
The officer arrests her for public intoxication. She goes to court, where she is convicted and slapped with a fine.
This actually happened to an Indianapolis woman, and she took the case all the way to the Indiana Supreme Court, which upheld her conviction last year.
The court ruled that Indiana law required only that a person be drunk in a public place to be charged with public intoxication, and according to a court decision from 1966, the inside of a vehicle traveling along a public road qualifies as a public place.
Lots of folks were appalled by the woman’s conviction and the court’s subsequent ruling.
The woman, they said, was doing exactly what all those public awareness campaigns had encouraged her to do. She was too drunk to drive, so she handed her keys to someone who was sober.
And she wound up getting arrested for public intoxication simply for getting a ride home.
What would the courts have had her do? Spend the night at the bar?
The folks behind those campaigns urging people to find a designated driver were afraid that a case like this might discourage people from following their advice. What good does it do to hand over your car keys if you’re going to end up being arrested anyway?
That’s an oversimplification, of course. Hundreds of people have done the right thing and managed to get home safely and without getting arrested.
Still, supporters of the bill say the woman’s case isn’t exactly unique.
They say that under the existing law, Hoosiers caught walking home or riding in a car with a designated driver are being charged basically for doing the right thing.
This isn’t, of course, the fault of the courts. Judges and prosecutors are simply enforcing the law on the books. So are the police officers making the arrests.
State law makes it a crime to be in a public place in a state of intoxication caused by the use of alcohol or drugs. Under that language, a woman who hands her keys to a friend is still violating the law when she gets into the car.
Such a law puts a person who has had too much to drink in an unreasonable position. You can’t walk home. You can’t get a ride home. You would pretty much have to stay where you are, and that’s not always feasible.
Lawmakers responded appropriately to the decision and set out to fix the flaw in Indiana law.
Senate Bill 97 requires a person not only to be drunk, but to be disruptive or dangerous before he or she can be charged with public intoxication. An intoxicated person must be endangering his or her own life, endangering someone else’s life or disturbing the peace, creating a disturbance or harassing another person.
Assuming the governor signs it, the new law will take effect July 1.
It’s a change that is long overdue.
• Kelly Hawes is managing editor of the Pharos-Tribune. He can be reached at 574-732-5155 or email@example.com.
Picture this scenario.
- HAYDEN: Differences in lists of wants Every year at about this time, Statehouse reporters like me ask lawmakers what their priorities will be for the coming year. The more interesting inquiry is made by the people at Ball State’s Bowen Center for Public Affairs because they ask Hoosiers
LYONS: The South keeps America interesting
For all the regional tensions in American politics, have you ever stopped to think what a boring country this would be without the South?
- HOWEY: Drs. Bucshon, Brown and the Obamacare era Larry Bucshon is a heart surgeon, a Republican and a congressman. He has had employees who have reached lifetime insurance caps and ended up on Medicaid. He has seen thousands of poor Hoosiers on Medicaid denied access to health care. He paid about $
- KNISELY: You can just call me Judy [Enter stage left, car-rying clear glass containing blue beverage, and place drink on table.] "Here you go." [Exit stage right.] I don't remember the name of the play or my character's name in the junior high production, but I do remember I was dress
- WOLFSIE: A black mark on Friday On Black Friday I was dealing with some severe back pain. What with the giant screen TVs, the treadmills, and the new furniture -- well, I never should have carried in all those newspaper ads from the front porch in one trip. My wife and I have alway
- PETERS: Mercury contamination from the old days When I was a younger and more sprightly woman, I spent part of my life investigating unusual hot springs in rural California. They were salty and quite stinky springs out in the middle of nowhere, and several of them occurred right in the center of a
- WILLIAMS: Unspoken holiday traditions I watched the Black Friday (now Thursday as well) carryings on - stamping and tramping and shoving and pushing, a willingness to engage in bloodshed for a parking space or an iPad and it seems to me that Thanksgiving contained the seeds to be a confl
- BOHANON: Adam Smith and the point of preschool The Indiana Legislature will likely consider expanding statewide pre-kindergarten (pre-K) programs for children at risk. Informing the discussion will be an extensively studied 1960s pre-K experiment, the Perry Program from Ypsilanti, Michigan. Its f
- PARKER: Food stamps and turkey tales If you peruse the news on any given day, the farm bill/food stamp debate produces two general impressions: Republicans are heartless turkey thieves; Democrats are spendthrift welfare caterers. If only neither were a little bit right. As with tabloid
- KITCHELL: One Merlyn had wit, wisdom, no magic In the annals of Cass County government, no one has ever served as county council president longer than a man from Walton who passed away last week. Merlyn Raikes was the first candidate from either party to serve five four-year terms on the council.
- More Columns Headlines