Pharos-Tribune

Columns

June 12, 2012

The price of making rain

If you hear someone talking about dry spells in Logansport, they could be referring to brown lawns or the last time a new industry came to the city to expand the labor force.

In fact, it’s been about a decade since new industries were regularly springing up in the industrial park south of Logansport adjacent to the airport.

As for the lack of rain we’re experiencing this month, there was a time in the 1800s when “rainmakers” were paid to launch chemicals into the sky to seed clouds in hopes they would sneeze raindrops.

Whether it worked or not is debatable, and that’s why the process is considered anything but a sure thing.

The same could be said for trying to end local economic dry spells by paying consultants to make the skies rain jobs on communities like ours. In the last week, Logansport officials have approved $130,000 in tax dollars that will be used to somehow “enhance” economic development.

In fairness to one of the consulting firms, William-Lynn-James, it has successfully worked with the city for years in promoting the soon-to-be-completed Hoosier Heartland from the Ohio state line to Lafayette. Although current Mayor Teddy Franklin once questioned the amount of money Logansport paid for lobbying efforts by the company when other larger cities paid less, Logansport arguably had more to gain from a four-lane highway than Lafayette, Fort Wayne or even Peru because those communities already had four-lane access.

But paying consultants on retainer for economic development efforts is a bit different and not exactly a no-brainer. Here’s why:

1. Retainers. There’s a reason why consultants and lawyers like to be paid this way because they may not succeed in doing what you want them to do. If any consultant was paid based on the actual number of jobs directly created by his or her expertise, we would all want to pay them as much as we could. Unfortunately, it doesn’t work that way. Hiring consultants to represent your community or to work the economic development circuit is spinning a huge roulette wheel that may not have a winner when the wheel stops turning.

2. Priorities. One of the reasons why Logansport and other communities don’t go the way the city is going now is because consultants are beholden to many masters, as in clients. Clients who pay the most for services would understandably expect the most out of consultants for their money and would likely reap the best fruits of their labors. Using local revenue to enhance economic development efforts through the existing Logansport-Cass County Economic Development Foundation puts more fuel in the tank of an organization that is responsible to only one community — ours.

3. The Indiana Economic Development Corporation. One of the real reasons this type of local expenditure is questionable is that the state of Indiana is already expected to provide this kind of service for Logansport, Cass County and other Indiana communities. The corporation that was known previously as the Indiana Department of Commerce has launched trade missions to other countries, some of which have involved our own local officials. If the state can’t showcase shovel-ready industrial sites in strategic locations like Logansport, then state officials can’t pose for all those groundbreaking ceremonies in glossy campaign mailings we usually receive in even-numbered years.

4. What we have to show for our money. Realistically, what we may have to show for this $130,000 appropriation in 10 years is — pause for swallowing hard — nothing, zilch, natta, empty set, zero.

Meanwhile, if $130,000 could be invested in local infrastructure, property acquisition to expand the industrial park, funding to support entrepreneurs or an incubator building to facilitate businesses growing from garages to warehouses, we would at least generate tangible assets that are permanent investments we can build upon over the next decade.

5. Our fair share. There’s plenty of talk in Congress about the naughty word “earmarks” because that word connotes special favors for favorite contributors or communities. But the fact of the matter is that Indiana ranks 22nd in per capita return of federal tax revenue. Directing William-Lynn-James to use its Washington lobbying connections to secure what Logansport and Cass County have coming could yield a substantial return.

Per capita, every American represents an average of $8,520 in federal tax revenue, but in Indiana, the per capita average is only $6,724. In other words, if Logansport had its actual fair share of federal tax revenue, it would have $36 million more to work with than it has today. Add in rural portions of Cass County and that’s more than $70 million more for a community that is starved for funds to pay for basic public safety and community development.

Just one year of $70 million would likely demolish every condemned property in the county that’s not on the tax rolls and build a home, office or factory in its place, creating a more stable tax base for the city and county.

Are city officials doing the economic development equivalent of paying a rainmaker? In essence, the answer is yes.

We have to hope for rain and maybe even pray for it. But do we really have to pay for it?

• Dave Kitchell is a columnist for the Pharos-Tribune. He can be reached through the newspaper at ptnews@pharostribune.com.

 

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Columns
  • FREY: An ode to service days gone by There were many times in the past year that I walked by the small glass corner curio cabinet.I often glanced at the photographs from the corners of my eyes as I made my way past the nurse’s station and out the pass-coded locked doors.It is one of man

    August 22, 2014

  • WOLFSIE: A matter of bad habits Mary Ellen and I have been happy together for so long that we sometimes forget how much we annoy each other, so on the trip back home from our recent vacation, it was time catch up on our bad habits.For example, I told Mary Ellen that she is a relent

    August 22, 2014

  • WILLIAMS: Life is not all choices There is a post on Facebook that says, “Everything you do is based on the choices you make. It’s not your parents, your past relationships, your job, the economy, the weather, an argument or your age that is to blame. You and only you are responsible

    August 21, 2014

  • HAMILTON: Why government openness matters One of the fundamental lessons of the 9/11 tragedy was that our government carried a share of blame for the failure to stop the attacks. Not because it was asleep at the switch or ignorant of the dangers that Al Qaeda posed, but because the agencies

    August 21, 2014

  • KITCHELL: Quality of life and leaders both matter It was with some astonishment and much disappointment I read in the Aug. 5 edition of the Pharos-Tribune that one of our local city councilmen was quoted as saying that previous efforts in Logansport to use Tax Increment Financing money for quality o

    August 20, 2014

  • RAMPELL: Here comes Entrepreneur Barbie WASHINGTON — Lego’s groundbreaking female-scientists set sold out almost immediately after it was released this month. But never fear, fans of feminist toys: A new Barbie doll, now in stock, is also shattering the plastic ceiling.Yes, that swan-necke

    August 20, 2014

  • MARCUS: Hoosier workers not gaining on the nation A few readers of the South Bend newspaper have sent emails complaining that either they do not understand my columns or that I waste their time by not sticking to the facts. That I include some of my conclusions from the data seems to be an irritant.

    August 19, 2014

  • VILLAGE IDIOT: Stock market guru will work for food At the height of its power, the photography company Kodak employed more than 140,000 people and was worth $28 billion dollars. They even invented the first digital camera. But today Kodak is bankrupt, and the new face of digital photography has becom

    August 19, 2014

  • HAYDEN: Craft brewers and vintners return to fair Brad Hawkins felt right at home hawking his beer at the Indiana State Fairgrounds last week. When Hawkins opened his Salt Creek Brewery in a converted filling station in tiny Needmore three years ago, some tee-totaling neighbors protested he was putt

    August 18, 2014

  • LYONS: Climate change deniers resort to attacks Recently a friend posted a video on Facebook that he asserted would demolish the Godless theory of evolution. On it, a fellow sitting in a pickup and wearing a backward baseball cap smugly explained that Darwinian evolution contradicts the Second Law

    August 18, 2014

Hyperlocal Search
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Poll

Does Indiana need a statewide water management plan and an administrator to implement it?

Yes
No
Unsure
     View Results
Featured Ads
AP Video
Furry Roommates: Dorms Allowing Cats and Dogs Chase Rice Defends Bro-Country 'Jersey Shore Massacre' Pokes Fun at MTV Series Raw: Wash. Mudslides Close Roads, Trap Motorists DC's Godfather of Go-Go Honored Ukraine Calls Russian Convoy a 'direct Invasion' Girl Meets Her 'one in the World' Match Coal Gas Boom in China Holds Climate Risks Japan Landslide Rescuers Struggle in Heavy Rain Raw: Severe Floods, Fire Wrecks Indiana Homes Endangered Red Wolves Face Uncertain Future Raw: Russian Aid Convoy Arrives in Ukraine Okla. Policeman Accused of Sex Assaults on Duty Dominican Republic Bans Miley Cyrus Concert Raw: Israeli Air Strike in Gaza Raw: Bodies of MH17 Victims Arrive in Malaysia Attorney: Utah Eatery Had Other Chemical Burn
Parade
Magazine

Click HERE to read all your Parade favorites including Hollywood Wire, Celebrity interviews and photo galleries, Food recipes and cooking tips, Games and lots more.